A Franchise Case Study's Network Number Can Hide Which Location Moved

A Franchise Case Study’s Network Number Can Hide Which Location Moved

You are looking at a case study credited to a franchise, a multi-brand portfolio, or a company with a dozen locations under one name. The headline number is one percentage. Before you decide what it tells you, it is worth asking a question the page itself does not answer: did every location contribute, or did one location do most of the work while the others rode along in the average?

The number on the page is a network number, not a location number

When a case study covers a franchise or a multi-brand portfolio, the headline figure is reported at the level of the group, not any single site. A network-wide percentage, whether it describes follower growth, posting activity, or engagement, is a statement about the aggregate across every location in scope for the period measured. It is not a claim that each location individually reached that number. Ten locations averaging forty percent growth could mean each grew by roughly forty percent, or it could mean nine grew barely at all and one grew enormously. The published number cannot tell the two apart on its own.

A useful real example is Flamel’s published case study for Home Run Franchises, a home-service franchise portfolio. The page reports, as network-wide figures belonging to Flamel and Home Run Franchises, audience growth of +305 percent, activity growth of +268 percent, engagement growth of +90 percent, and more than $1.5k in earned media value. Every one of those numbers describes the network as a whole, not any individual franchise location.

This is a different mechanism than an agency’s portfolio average

It is worth naming the distinction between this and a mechanism this site has covered before: one outlier account skewing an agency’s portfolio average. That case involves separate, unrelated clients who each hired the same agency independently. One client’s unusually strong result pulls the agency’s reported average up, even though the other clients’ results were ordinary.

A franchise or multi-brand network number is a different kind of aggregation. It aggregates locations or brands that belong to the same parent company and were deliberately reported together as a single network metric. The fix is different too. For a skewed portfolio average, ask for the median or the distribution across clients. For a franchise network number, ask a narrower question: which locations were actually in scope for the period measured, and were all of them included on the same terms.

What the Home Run Franchises case study actually discloses about scope

The Home Run Franchises page names three brands in the portfolio: Up Closets, Dryer Vent Superheroes, and The Lighting Squad. But the case study states that the platform was used for “their Dryer Vent Superheroes and Up Closets locations for a year.” That sentence names two of the three brands, not three. The Lighting Squad appears in the opening description of the portfolio, but the disclosed usage period is specific to the other two.

This leaves a real, unresolved question. The page does not break out how much of the +305 percent follower growth, the +268 percent activity growth, or the +90 percent engagement growth came from Dryer Vent Superheroes locations versus Up Closets locations, or whether growth was even across the individual franchise locations within either brand. Both readings are consistent with the same aggregate figure.

There is a smaller disclosure worth noticing too. The one named quote in the case study comes from a Brand Manager at Dryer Vent Superheroes, not from someone in a Home Run corporate role who would plausibly speak for the whole portfolio. That does not make the quote untrue. It means the single voice quoted is positioned at one brand within the disclosed scope, not above it.

The four questions that separate a shared result from a masked one

  • How many locations or brands were actually in the measured group, and does that number appear on the page?
  • Does the case study disclose a range across locations, best performer, typical performer, worst performer, or only the aggregate?
  • Were all locations live on the same program for the same period, or did some join partway through?
  • Is the quoted testimonial from someone positioned to speak for the whole network, or the one location that likely drove the number?

A hypothetical worked example: same 40 percent headline, two very different realities

The following example is entirely hypothetical, invented for illustration with round numbers, and not tied to any real company or case study.

Scenario A (hypothetical): a ten-location franchise network reports 40 percent average follower growth. Every one of the ten locations grew somewhere between 32 and 48 percent, a genuinely shared result.

Scenario B (hypothetical): the same network reports the identical 40 percent average, but nine of the ten locations grew by roughly 4 percent each, ordinary and unremarkable, while the tenth grew by 364 percent after an unrelated post went unexpectedly viral. That single location alone is enough to pull the ten-location average up to 40 percent.

The network-wide number cannot distinguish Scenario A from Scenario B on its own. Only a disclosed range across locations, or a per-location breakdown, can tell a reader which one they are looking at.

What a franchise case study would need to show to rule out a single-location result

Disclosure needed What it would rule out
A stated count of locations in scope for the period Ambiguity about how large the measured group actually was
A range or median alongside the average A single strong location quietly carrying the reported average
Confirmation every location was live for the full window A result inflated by locations added partway through the period

Where to go next

If a franchise or multi-location case study lands in front of you and you want to see more entries in this pattern, browse the case study library, or submit your own if you have a result you can back up with the scope disclosures this piece describes.

FAQ

If a franchise case study reports one network-wide percentage, does that mean every location hit that number?

No. A network-wide percentage is a statement about the aggregate across every location or brand in scope. It does not say whether growth was even across locations or concentrated in one, as the hypothetical Scenario A and Scenario B above show.

What did the Home Run Franchises case study actually disclose about which brands were included?

It names three brands, Up Closets, Dryer Vent Superheroes, and The Lighting Squad, but states the platform was used for “their Dryer Vent Superheroes and Up Closets locations for a year.” It does not break the percentages out by brand or location, and the quoted testimonial comes from a Dryer Vent Superheroes brand manager.

Sources

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *